Alfa Romeo’s Junior takes on VW’s Golf GTI. Passion vs Precision.

This is not the definitive road test of all road tests to try to unseat the GTI with a Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV). But very few who encountered the Junior thought that it looked like a crossover or compact SUV. And even fewer thought it was a ‘boring’ BEV. Most thought it looked like a sexy hot hatch that must haul.

And when I looked at the power and torque figures, I thought, what the heck, let’s throw the King of hot hatches, VW’s Golf GTI, into the mix for a bit of fun. I mean, everybody out on the road is just as keen to line a GTI up. Why can’t we?

With the on-paper numbers listed below, you can now see why I thought these two could be an interesting comparison. The Junior is all silent yet fast. The GTI offering wheelspin and noise is also fast. Two very different approaches to how these manufacturers go about getting their thrills to the owners of their cars.

ALSO READ: Alfa Romeo Junior wears poisoned chalice with proper ‘passione’

Alfa Romeo Junior Elettrica Veloce

• Power – 206Kw
• Torque – 345Nm
• Aspiration – 54kWh battery
• Weight – 1 689kg
• Drive – Front wheels
• Gearbox – Single-speed
• Claimed 0-100km/h – 5.9-seconds
• Price – R999 900

VW Golf 8 GTI

• Power – 180 kW
• Torque – 370Nm
• Aspiration – Turbo petrol
• Weight – 1 351kg
• Drive – Front wheels
• Gearbox – Seven-speed
• Claimed 0-100km/h – 6.2-seconds
• Price – R853 400

The Junior is as firm as all hell on the road, but I kinda expected that. And the snug Sabelt race bucket seats, which can be added as an option, add to the feeling that this is more of a hot hatch than a family-friendly SUV.

I enjoyed that it let you think you could throw it around like a go-kart. But obviously, near the limit, you can’t escape the extra weight the battery adds to the mix. Is the VW Golf GTI more engaging to drive? Better in the twisties? And more passenger-friendly with a softer ride?

Of course, it is, but I must admit, I enjoyed my week in the Junior playing racer boy in the suburbs. The world today will never allow it, but chuck out that heavy battery and put a proper petrol engine under the hood, and just maybe the tables could be turned.

I am going to very briefly touch on fuel/battery consumption before moving to what happened when I strapped my RaceLogic VBOX equipment to the cars. The Junior averaged 21.3 kWh per 100 km. This comes to R80 to do 100 km. So, around 4.0 litres per 100km.

The GTI, on the other hand, burned through just short of 10.0 litres per 100km. Which is more than decent for a hot hatch, but twice as expensive as the Junior. Yes, one is going to need a few stops for charging on the way down to the coast, and the other will get there on a single tank. You decide your poison.

Right. Onto Gerotek. This went way closer than it should have. The GTI gets off the line 0.3 seconds quicker than the Junior, which has a little think about life before unleashing its power. It’s this 0.3 of a second that separates them at 100km/h.

The GTI goes better than claimed, as they always do, and posted a time of 5.88 seconds. The Junior came through at 6.15 seconds. Fractionally slower than claimed.

At the quarter-mile mark, the gap is the same 0.3 seconds, and the trap speed of the GTI is only 1.2km/h over the Junior. 14.06 seconds and 165.51 km/h to 14.40 seconds and 164.26 km/h, respectively.

At 800m, they are less than one second apart, but then the Junior’s electronics pull it up to 200 km/h, as indicated on the clock. The GTI obviously goes barreling past till it hits 250km/h. One is made for high-speed open road driving. The other not.

In acceleration terms, the Junior fights back and is quicker than the GTI in all the in-gear overtaking tests. This can obviously be attributed to the instant torque provided by the electric motor and the single-speed gearbox, which is always ready to go.

ALSO READ: Alfa Romeo’s EV future will include new SUV and retention of Giulia

Road test figures

As I said, it was closer than we thought, and ultimately, this was a silly comparison, but we did it because we can. We know that no VW Golf GTI driver is going to trade in his car for a battery-electric Alfa Romeo Junior. But maybe, just maybe, the doomsayers will give the Alfa Romeo Junior Electrica Veloce a bit of credit for still being a bit dynamic and fun to drive for an electric car.

Support Local Journalism

Add The Citizen as a Preferred Source on Google and follow us on Google News to see more of our trusted reporting in Google News and Top Stories.